Sony WH-1000XM5 / XM6 and Bose headphones sound bad on Mac calls: the cause and fix
It isn't your headphones. Bluetooth headsets, Sony and Bose included, drop to a mono call profile when a Mac app opens their mic, usually at 8 or 16 kHz. Use the Mac's built-in mic (or a USB mic) for the call and keep the headphones as the speaker, or use a wired headset. An app such as CallLane can keep the Mac's mic as the system input after reconnects, for call apps set to the system default.
Written from Apple’s and the app makers’ own documentation and the CallLane 1.0.5 source, . Not yet tested with Sony or Bose headphones.
CallLane keeps your music at full volume on calls and your AirPods in high quality. One-time purchase, 14-day refund.
Buy $9Why they sound fine for music and bad on calls
Bluetooth headphones have a listening mode, stereo and high quality, and a headset mode that carries the mic. They can’t do both at once. When Zoom, Teams, FaceTime or Discord starts using the headphones’ mic, they switch to headset mode, and Apple says audio quality and volume drop until the mic is no longer in use. You hear the call, and anything else playing, through a narrow mono channel.
In headset mode, Bluetooth carries the sound both ways through a speech codec: CVSD at 8 kHz or mSBC at 16 kHz on most headphones. On AirPods 3 and the original AirPods Pro, a developer who read macOS’s logs in February 2022 found AAC-ELD at 24 kHz (reported here). On AirPods Pro 3 with macOS 27.0.1, I measured their sound at 24 kHz mono while the mic was open (the measurement); macOS doesn’t say which codec that is. All of these are mono and far below the stereo of the listening mode.
A WH-1000XM5 or a QuietComfort uses the same Bluetooth profiles as any other headset, so it drops the same way. Owners ask about it on r/SonyHeadphones and r/bose, and Sony’s support steps I found cover Windows, not the Mac. Some Sony models support LE Audio, which can carry better call audio, but macOS doesn’t support LE Audio.
The fix: Mac mic in, headphones out
- Open System Settings, then Sound, then Input, and pick the Mac’s built-in mic or a USB mic. Close the window afterwards.
- Keep Output on your Sony or Bose headphones.
- In each call app, set the mic to System default or the same mic by name. FaceTime has it in the Video menu, Zoom under Settings, Audio, Discord under User Settings, Voice & Video.
The headphones stay in listening mode for the whole call. People hear your Mac’s mic instead of the headset mic, which on a MacBook is usually the better of the two in a quiet room. In a noisy room, a wired or USB headset is the better trade.
If your headphones are also connected to your phone
Multipoint headphones can jump between the phone and the Mac. One XM5 owner on Apple’s forum lost the mic on the Mac after taking a phone call. If the mic or sound disappears after a phone call, disconnect and reconnect the headphones from the Mac’s Bluetooth settings, then check the input again.
Apps that keep the Mac’s mic as the input
macOS makes the headphones the input again whenever they reconnect. MicLock is free and its page names the Sony WH-1000XM4, XM5 and XM6. SoundAnchor and Mic Check are paid. Every option compared (the page says AirPods, but they all work by the input, not the brand).
Where CallLane fits
CallLane’s Lock input holds the Mac’s system input on the mic you pick and switches it back when macOS or an app moves it. It doesn’t check what brand your headphones are; it only keeps their mic from being the system input. I haven’t tested it with Sony or Bose headphones myself. Like the other apps, it can’t change a call app that names the headset mic directly, so do step 3 once. It also stops calls from turning your music down, a separate macOS behaviour.
Questions
Why do my Sony WH-1000XM5 sound bad on Zoom on a Mac?
Zoom is using the headphones' mic, which switches Bluetooth to headset mode: mono audio, usually at 8 or 16 kHz. Set Zoom's microphone to the Mac's built-in mic and keep the headphones as the speaker.
Is it a fault with my Bose headphones?
No. Every Bluetooth headset drops to headset mode when its mic is in use. Wired headphones don't.